Free preview·Day 4 of 5 — read all 5 free, then join the waitlist for the rest.
Join waitlistDay 4
The Competitive Blind Spot
Most print shop owners have a vague sense of their competition. They know the big online printers exist. They see local competitors' storefronts. But they lack a structured analysis of who competes for which clients, at what price points, with what advantages. This blindness leads to competing on price by default rather than competing on value by design.
Learning Objectives
- Build a competitive landscape matrix for your market
- Identify where competitors are weak and you are strong
- Determine which competitors actually threaten your target clients
The Four Competitive Categories
Not all competitors are equal threats. Categorize them:
1. Large Online Printers: Vistaprint, Moo, GotPrint, and others. They compete on price and convenience. They lack personal service, custom consultation, and complex job capability. They threaten your smallest, most price-sensitive clients.
2. Local Independent Print Shops: Direct competitors in your geography. Some compete on price. Others compete on service. A few compete on specialty capability. These are your most relevant competitors for local corporate clients.
3. Franchise Print Networks: FedEx Office, The UPS Store, Sir Speedy, Minuteman Press. They have brand recognition and established processes. They may lack flexibility and personalized senior attention.
4. In-House Print Operations: Some large companies bring printing in-house. This is a threat for high-volume commodity work but rarely a threat for complex, multi-format, or variable-data jobs.
Competitive Analysis Framework
For each direct competitor in your market, document:
| Factor | Your Business | Competitor A | Competitor B | Competitor C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Services offered | ||||
| Price positioning | ||||
| Turnaround time | ||||
| Online ordering | ||||
| Design services | ||||
| Delivery options | ||||
| Account management | ||||
| Web-to-print portal | ||||
| Wide format capability | ||||
| Direct mail services | ||||
| Reviews/rating | ||||
| Years in business | ||||
| Target market |
Action Step: Complete this matrix for your top 3 competitors. Be honest. Overstating your advantages serves no one.
Finding Your Competitive Gap
After completing the matrix, look for patterns:
- Where is everyone competing? (Usually on price for commodity items)
- Where is no one competing? (Usually in specialized services, web-to-print, or white-glove account management)
- Where can you win decisively? (Your intersection of capability, expertise, and market need)
The gap is your positioning opportunity.
Common Gaps in the Commercial Printing Market
- True web-to-print portals with branded templates for corporate clients (most local shops lack this)
- End-to-end direct mail including list acquisition, design, print, and fulfillment
- Wide format and installation services as a bundled offering
- Marketing consultation beyond order-taking
- Guaranteed turnaround times with financial backing
- Dedicated account management for mid-market clients
Today's Deliverable
Complete the Competitive Landscape Matrix and write a one-paragraph positioning statement that describes where you will win and how you are different from the three nearest competitors.
Key Takeaway
You do not need to be better than every competitor at everything. You need to be dramatically better than every competitor at the specific things your ideal clients value most. Competitive clarity eliminates price competition and creates pricing power.